Archive

Archive for the ‘Comparison between Diffrent Tags’ Category

Comparison between external and internal RFID tags for animal identification

June 6th, 2009 Manthan Bhavsar No comments

Sr No.

Internal (Injectable) Tags

External (Ear) Tags

Ruminal Bolus

1.

Needs pre sterilized needles or disposable syringes for injecting.

Does not need sterilization. Just needs spray of anti bacterial on the external area.

Needs bolus guns, sterility may be an issue. Also need monitoring in initial days

2.

No way of finding if an animal is injected or not as India has smaller holding of cattle. May need external tag just to identify the injected ones.

Easily identifiable. Farmer can read the numbers for sms based/phone based information system and authentication.

No way of finding if an animal is injected or not as India has smaller holding of cattle. May need external tag just to identify the injected ones.

3.

Difficult to identify location

No such issue

Needs patient probing for ID. Not always successful in muddy, filthy animals. Needs skin contact probing for read.

4.

Perfection is needed for injection as it is sub-cutaneous and not intravenous. (It should be parallel to skin and not penetrative)

VOs and others already trained for ear tagging

Perfection is needed for bolus administration and monitoring.

5.

Difficult to remove after death for purpose of insurance

Easy to cut off

Difficult to remove after death for purpose of insurance

6.

Permanent and non intrusive.

Permanent and non intrusive.

Permanent and non intrusive